The Top 5 Legal Risks of Digital Inaccessibility for Executives

Jeffrey Rodgers

September 05 8 min read

Digital accessibility presents a significant challenge for company executives. Many leaders mistakenly view it as a simple fix or an expensive investment with poor returns. This misconception leaves businesses vulnerable to legal and reputational risks.

The complexity of digital accessibility often overwhelms executive teams. They struggle to understand which laws apply to their websites and digital assets, and strategies for implementing accessibility measures across an organization remain unclear. This lack of clarity extends beyond customer-facing platforms to internal systems used by employees, compounding the potential for legal exposure.

As the digital landscape evolves, so do the legal implications of inaccessibility. Executives must recognize that accessibility is not just a compliance checkbox but a fundamental aspect of inclusive business practices. Understanding the top legal risks associated with digital inaccessibility is crucial for protecting your company. Let’s explore the first major risk: lawsuits under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

Don’t forget to download our free Accessiblü guide on ADA Laws for Businesses

Risk 1: ADA Lawsuits and Legal Compliance

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) isn’t just about physical accessibility—it’s a digital imperative. The Department of Justice has clarified that websites and mobile apps fall under ADA jurisdiction, raising the stakes for businesses of all sizes.

Consider this scenario: A national retailer faces a class-action lawsuit because screen reader users can’t navigate their website. Or picture a local government sued over inaccessible online services. These aren’t hypothetical situations—they’re happening right now.

To shield your organization from such legal perils, consider these strategies:

Appoint a Chief Accessibility Officer or designate an executive sponsor to champion compliance efforts.
Conduct regular accessibility audits, combining automated tools with manual testing by users with disabilities.
Integrate accessibility into your digital strategy from the ground up, ensuring all teams—from design to content creation—are aligned with accessibility goals.

Remember, accessibility isn’t a one-time fix. It’s an ongoing commitment that requires executive oversight and company-wide dedication. By prioritizing accessibility at the highest levels of your organization, you’re not just avoiding lawsuits—you’re opening doors to a broader audience and demonstrating corporate responsibility.

Risk 2: Section 508 Non-Compliance and Federal Contracts

While ADA compliance is crucial, it’s not the only legal minefield in the digital accessibility landscape. Enter Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act—a regulation that extends its reach beyond government agencies to private companies doing business with them.

Section 508 mandates that all electronic and information technology (EIT) used by federal agencies must be accessible to individuals with disabilities. This includes software, websites, and digital platforms provided by contractors. The stakes? Lucrative government contracts and potential legal challenges.

Picture this: A software provider loses a multi-million-dollar federal contract because their product fails to meet Section 508 standards. Or consider a government contractor facing legal action after delivering an inaccessible online platform to a federal agency. These scenarios are not just hypothetical—they’re very real risks for businesses in the federal sector.

To safeguard your company from these pitfalls, consider implementing these strategies:

Develop accurate Voluntary Product Accessibility Templates (VPATs) for all products and services provided to federal agencies.
Invest in comprehensive Section 508 compliance training for all teams designing, developing, and delivering digital products.
Forge strategic partnerships with accessibility experts who can provide ongoing support and ensure your products comply with evolving standards.

Remember, Section 508 compliance isn’t just about ticking boxes—it’s about opening doors to substantial business opportunities while fostering inclusive digital environments. By prioritizing accessibility in your federal contracting efforts, you’re not just avoiding legal risks but positioning your company as a leader in inclusive technology.

Risk 3: State-Level Legal Actions and Jurisdictional Variability

While federal laws set the baseline for digital accessibility, the legal landscape becomes even more complex when you factor in state-specific regulations. Each state has the power to enact its own accessibility laws, often more stringent than federal standards. This patchwork of regulations creates a minefield for businesses operating across multiple jurisdictions.

Take California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act, for instance. It packs a punch with statutory damages for non-compliance, raising the stakes for businesses in the Golden State. But California isn’t alone – New York and other states have their own robust accessibility requirements.

Link to StubHub Class Action Lawsuit article

This jurisdictional variability poses significant challenges:

A California-based e-commerce platform might face multiple lawsuits under the Unruh Act, resulting in hefty statutory damages.
A company with a national presence could struggle to maintain consistent user experiences while complying with differing state requirements.

To navigate this complex legal terrain, consider these strategies:

Conduct comprehensive legal reviews regularly to stay informed about accessibility requirements in all states where you operate.
Adopt WCAG 2.2 AA as your universal standard. This approach ensures you meet (and often exceed) compliance across all jurisdictions.
Provide tailored training to your legal and compliance teams on state-specific accessibility laws.

Remember, proactivity is key. Don’t wait for a lawsuit to start taking state-level accessibility seriously. By staying ahead of the curve, you’re not just mitigating legal risks – you’re opening your digital doors to a wider nationwide audience.

Risk 4: Reputational Damage and Loss of Consumer Trust

Your digital presence is often the first impression you make. When that presence isn’t accessible, you’re not just risking legal action—you’re putting your reputation on the line.

Imagine this: A viral social media campaign highlighting your website’s inaccessibility leads to a significant drop in sales. Or an investigative report uncovers widespread accessibility issues across your digital platforms, creating a PR nightmare. These scenarios aren’t just hypothetical—they’re very real risks in our increasingly inclusive society.

Consumers expect more than just products or services; they demand inclusivity and social responsibility. When businesses fail to provide accessible digital experiences, they risk more than just losing potential customers with disabilities. They face backlash from a broader public that values and supports inclusive practices.

The Ripple Effect of Inaccessibility

Negative publicity can spread like wildfire across social media platforms
Consumer boycotts can lead to significant revenue losses
Damage to brand image can have long-lasting impacts on customer loyalty

So, how can you shield your brand from these reputational risks? Consider these proactive strategies:

Publicly commit to digital accessibility through an official statement on your website
Regularly update stakeholders on your accessibility efforts and progress
Actively engage with disability rights organizations for feedback and collaboration
Develop a crisis management plan specifically for addressing accessibility-related issues

Remember, in the court of public opinion, actions speak louder than words. By prioritizing accessibility, you’re not just protecting your reputation—you’re building a brand that truly resonates with all consumers.

Think it can’t happen to you? Dunkin, Marriott, Ring, and Ralph Lauren are just some of the more prominent names that have had lawsuits against them in 2024.

Top Disability Class Action Lawsuits

Risk 5: Increased Litigation from Advocacy Groups

The landscape of digital accessibility is rapidly evolving, and advocacy groups are at the forefront of this change. These organizations are no longer waiting for businesses to catch up—they’re taking proactive legal action to ensure digital equality.

Disability rights organizations increasingly initiate class-action lawsuits or partner with individuals to file high-profile cases. The financial and reputational impact of such litigation can be severe, especially if it leads to a publicized settlement or court ruling.

Consider these scenarios:

A national restaurant chain faces a lawsuit from an advocacy group over an inaccessible online ordering system, resulting in a costly settlement and mandated changes.
A prominent financial services company becomes entangled in a class-action lawsuit for failing to provide accessible online banking services, leading to widespread negative media coverage.

To mitigate these risks, consider implementing the following strategies:

Conduct regular third-party accessibility audits of your digital platforms. These assessments should be comprehensive and include input from users with disabilities.
As part of your broader risk management strategy, work with legal experts to assess the potential risks of litigation related to digital inaccessibility.
Take a collaborative approach by proactively engaging with advocacy groups. Understanding their concerns and working together to improve accessibility can help you avoid litigation and demonstrate your commitment to inclusivity.

Remember, these organizations aren’t out to get you—they’re pushing for a more inclusive digital world. By embracing their mission and working proactively to improve accessibility, you can turn potential adversaries into powerful allies in your journey toward digital inclusion.

CaseText Listing for WCAG/ADA Lawsuits

Embracing Accessibility as a Business Imperative

The digital world is evolving, and with it, the expectations for inclusivity. Accessibility isn’t just a checkbox on your compliance list—it’s a powerful tool for growth and innovation. By prioritizing accessibility, you’re not only mitigating legal risks but also tapping into a vast market of users who appreciate and seek out inclusive digital experiences.

Remember, accessibility benefits everyone. From improved SEO to enhanced usability for all users, the ripple effects of an accessible digital presence extend far beyond compliance. It’s time to shift your perspective: view accessibility not as an expense but as an investment in your company’s future. By integrating accessibility into your core business strategy, you’re fostering innovation, expanding your customer base, and building a more resilient organization.

As you navigate the complex waters of digital accessibility, don’t hesitate to seek expert guidance. Consult with legal professionals to understand your business’s specific compliance requirements. Engage with accessibility specialists to develop a comprehensive, long-term strategy. By taking proactive steps today, you’re not just avoiding potential pitfalls—you’re positioning your company as a leader in the inclusive digital revolution of tomorrow.

The Top 5 Legal Risks of Digital Inaccessibility for Executives

Risk 1: ADA Lawsuits and Legal Compliance

Risk 2: Section 508 Non-Compliance and Federal Contracts

Risk 3: State-Level Legal Actions and Jurisdictional Variability

Risk 4: Reputational Damage and Loss of Consumer Trust

The Ripple Effect of Inaccessibility

Risk 5: Increased Litigation from Advocacy Groups

Embracing Accessibility as a Business Imperative

Services

About

Resources

Contact Us

The Top 5 Legal Risks of Digital Inaccessibility for Executives

Risk 1: ADA Lawsuits and Legal Compliance

Risk 2: Section 508 Non-Compliance and Federal Contracts

Risk 3: State-Level Legal Actions and Jurisdictional Variability

Risk 4: Reputational Damage and Loss of Consumer Trust

The Ripple Effect of Inaccessibility

Risk 5: Increased Litigation from Advocacy Groups

Embracing Accessibility as a Business Imperative

Related Articles

Services

About

Resources

Contact Us